£100k fine for Belgravia basement collapse fatality

Arlindo Visentin, 58, from Brazil, was helping three other workers build a basement at a private property in London’s Belgravia district when he was crushed by a wall of gravel and clay weighing between three and five tonnes that collapsed.

His employer, contractor Nadeem Aftab, was yesterday fined in connection with the tragic incident that happened during the construction of a basement at a house in Wilton Row, Westminster.

The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) prosecuted Mr Aftab of Rosebury Road, Fulham, who pleaded guilty to breaching Section 2(1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974. He was fined £100,000 and ordered to pay costs of £61,590.

The Old Bailey heard that on 13 June 2007 Mr Visentin was working in the basement area of the house in Wilton Row, Westminster, when the collapse took place. He was completely buried with clay and gravel, causing fatal crush injures.

The HSE investigation found the temporary works required to support the earth during the underpinning operation were not adequately planned.

The earth that remained following the underpinning of the walls was not properly supported, and at the time of the incident no measures were in place to prevent falls into the excavation.

Mr Aftab failed to make sure the workers on site were trained, qualified and competent to carry out underpinning.

The HSE also suspects that language barriers may have been a contributory factor. Following the hearing, HSE inspector Lisa Chappell said: "Mr Visentin spoke very little English and did not share a common language with any of the other workers or with Mr Aftab.

"This incident highlights the need to have effective worker consultation and communication with all employees to ensure they understand the control measures that should be in place to prevent harm.

"Basement conversions involving underpinning are significant engineering projects and should be planned and managed by competent people. As a part of this, a competent temporary works engineer should design an appropriate sequence of works, and the work should be actively managed by a person who had the necessary knowledge, training and experience to ensure it is carried out safely."

Got a story? Email news@theconstructionindex.co.uk