The Health & Safety Executive (HSE) prosecuted Wrexham Demolition & Dismantling Ltd following the incident which took place on 9 September 2008.
Cardiff Crown Court heard that two employees, who do not wish to be named, were dismantling the internal structure of a building at the former NEG factory on Ocean Way in Cardiff.
As part of this work a mezzanine floor needed to be demolished. Most of the mezzanine floor had been removed without incident but an alternative method was required for the last section in order to protect air-conditioning units fixed to the end wall. The method of work adopted for this last section of the mezzanine floor was significantly different and more complex that had been adopted previously.
The company failed to recognise and adapt to the different hazards inherent in the revised system of work and as the employees began to dismantle the floor, a section collapsed, trapping them beneath it.
One employee sustained cracks to his spine and lost the toes and ball of his left foot resulting in him needing a prosthesis. His colleague suffered multiple fractures to his arms, a dislocated elbow and cracked ribs, as well as severe bruising to his back and kidneys.
The court was told that the method of work chosen to demolish the last part of the floor was unacceptable and dangerous.
HSE’s investigation revealed that the company had put the safety of its employees at risk by failing to ensure the specific requirements of the job were adequately assessed, planned and supervised.
Wrexham Demolition & Dismantling Ltd of Tank Farm Road, Llandarcy, Neath Port Talbot pleaded guilty to breaching Section 2 (1) of the Health and Safety at Work etc Act 1974 and was fined £30,000 and ordered to pay costs of £100,074.
Speaking after the hearing, HSE inspector Wayne Williams said: “Demolition work is recognised as being a particularly dangerous activity. As a result, it is essential that the work is properly planned and managed, and then carried out in accordance with a robust and safe system of work.
“Two employees of Wrexham Demolition and Dismantling Limited were involved in pre-weakening the supporting pillars of a section of mezzanine floor when it collapsed upon them. The direct cause of the accident was the choice of a totally unacceptable and dangerous method of work to demolish this part of the floor section. The likelihood of the floor prematurely collapsing due to this work was entirely foreseeable but it had not been taken into consideration. The company failed to ensure that the work was adequately assessed, planned and supervised. Consequently, no preventive or mitigating measures had been put in place to reflect the risk of the floor collapsing while the men were working beneath it.
“Both men were put in considerable danger by the choice of the method of work employed by Wrexham Demolition. Both men sustained serious injuries as a result of being struck by the falling masonry and if it were not for their quick thinking, and large element of good fortune, this incident could quite easily have had fatal consequences.”
Got a story? Email news@theconstructionindex.co.uk
